Stay
Home Page      Genres      

Stay

Review by Mack Bates
for Reel Movie Critic

H H

Cast

Ewan McGregor Dr. Sam Foster
Naomi Watts Lila Culpepper
Ryan Gosling Henry Letham
Janeane Garofalo Dr. Beth Levy
B.D. Wong Dr. Ren
Bob Hoskins Dr. Leon Patterson
Kate Burton Mrs. Letham
Directed by Marc Forster. Written by David Benioff. Thriller/Suspense. Rated R (for language and some disturbing images). Twentieth Century Fox. Running time: 98 minutes.

Analyze this?

In recent years, Hollywood has produced any number of films that present themselves as one thing, turn on a dime, and become something else entirely. "Jacob’s Ladder," "The Crying Game," "Primal Fear," "Fight Club," and last year’s Oscar® winner for best picture, "Million Dollar Baby," are all examples of recent films that feature major plot twists.

Add the new psychological thriller "Stay" to that growing list of films that promise to shock and awe moviegoers.

At the film’s open, art student Henry Letham (Ryan Gosling) sits on the roadway, in a traffic lane on the Brooklyn Bridge, a few yards away from a burning SUV. Apparently the only survivor of the accident in which he lost his parents and girlfriend, Henry visits Dr. Sam Foster (Ewan McGregor), a young psychiatrist who inherits Henry from a troubled colleague (Janeane Garofalo). The further he digs, Sam realizes that his new patient isn’t coping with the trauma induced by the accident, made all the more evident by Henry’s seemingly increased paranoia and possible psychosis.

The stakes are raised further when Henry begins to make vague predictions that begin to come true and starts administering a handful of miracles to people, including a mentor of Sam’s, played by Bob Hoskins. Once Henry reveals that he plans to commit suicide on the eve of his 21st birthday, the case hits Sam close to home due to his live-in girlfriend’s (Naomi Watts) past bout with depression that led to an unsuccessful suicide attempt. As Sam races against the clock to stop Henry from following through with his plan, his own sanity is put to the test as the line between reality and fantasy is blurred.

Directed by Marc Forster ("Monster’s Ball" and "Finding Neverland"), and written by David Benioff ("Troy" and "25th Hour"), "Stay" is a hyperactive potboiler that nearly jumps the shark in a questionable attempt to outwit even the most perceptive of moviegoers. At times during the film, one wonders what the filmmakers are attempting to pull off. Is this a meditation on the mysterious workings of the dreamscape? Is this an attempt to compare and contrast one reality to another? Is this the cinematic equivalent of an acid trip?

Whatever it ultimately is, this convoluted film is partly redeemed by the participation of Ewan McGregor and Naomi Watts headlining a solid cast. McGregor, donning a more convincing American accent than Orlando Bloom in "Elizabethtown," is captivating to watch as he slowly starts to question his own grip on reality while trying to help a troubled young man. Watts tackles a role that could have been largely one-dimensional with the fortitude we’ve come to expect of her. But as good as they both are in the middle of this chaotic mess, it’s rising star Gosling who steals the show. Anyone who has seen his previous work, notably his breakout performances in "The Believer" and "The Notebook" is keenly aware that he’s an actor to watch. Bob Hoskins, in a scene-stealing turn, also compensates for the film’s shortcomings.

The film’s hyper-stylized camerawork and editing is either an asset or a drawback depending on whom you ask. In the end one thing’s certain: "Stay" is more bewildering than entertaining.

Mack Bates © 2005

mack@reelmoviecritic.com

 

     

Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress

Home Page    Genres          Asia                  Coming of Age

Review by Shelley Cameron
For Reel Movie Critic

ê ê ê

Cast

Xun Zhou Little Chinese Seamstress
Kun Chen Luo
Ye Liu Ma
Directed by Dai Sijie. Drama / Coming of age. Not Rated. Empire Pictures. Running time: 111 minutes. In Mandarin and French with English subtitles.

Remembrance of things past

Based on his best selling novel of the same title, writer/director Dai Sijie recalls the period of his youth in the early 1970’s during China’s mountain village to be re-educated from his bourgeois existence intothe way of life according to Mao’s Little Red Book. The semi-autobiographical tale of friendship, love, and the transformative power of literature is tempered by the political mood in China but softened by the remote location where, in spite of the village chief’s best efforts to follow Mao’s directive, life goes on.

The purity of that stage of life on the cusp of adulthood is the dominant theme and the film is curiously devoid of much of the anxiety associated with the Cultural Revolution. It is foremost an episodic chronicle of four years for best friends Luo and Ma, deemed sons of privilege by the party. Though ill-equipped for the harsh tasks of village life, they are bright and bold enough to adapt and to manipulate by using the abilities they bring from their well-off childhoods. Luo, the son of a dentist, is handy rigging up a makeshift drill to fix a toothache for the chief. Ma’s violin is a curiosity and his talent with a Mozart sonata, rechristened "Mozart is playing for Chairman Mao" gains him favor with the chief. Since few of the villagers are literate, the duo is soon acting as traveling interpreters for the party-approved movies shown in a nearby town. They return to "tell films" to the eager villagers. On one such trek, they meet the Little Seamstress, the granddaughter of the local tailor.

The lush mountain scenery takes center stage at the outset as the boys climb a multitude of ancient stone steps to reach the village. Against the tumultuous time in China, the elected Communist chief takes his job seriously and demonstrates to the villagers and to Luo and Ma how he will purge them of their bourgeois ways with the honest hard work of peasant life. Sijie‘s viewpoint is an optimistic one and is reflected in the harmonic score, weighty with flutes and violins, and visual style that accentuates the fertile beauty of the region.

While the Cultural Revolution presumably thunders in far away Beijing, and Luo and Ma are changed by it, it brings far more change to the Little Seamstress. A spirited and smart 17 year old, and known only by her occupation, the trio form an alliance devoted to reading the forbidden literature of the west. After pinching a suitcase full of the banned books from a fellow student, Luo reads the French classics of Balzac, Dumas, and Flaubert to the Little Seamstress while Ma forms the third side to the sometimes uneasy triangle. The subsequent freedom of the soul liberates her from life as she has known it, and there is no going back. The sentimental reminiscence is no doubt colored by Sijie’s pentimento of the past but is nevertheless sweet and tender.

The touching conclusion leaps ahead 20 years to 1994 and illustrates the heartbreaking hazards of trying to go recapture one’s youth, proving the old adage that you can’t go home again. Sijie spent many years after leaving China and living in France and though his film may not be shown in his native land, it serves as a reminder that all minds are free.

Shelley Cameron © 2005

Shelley@reelmoviecritic.com

 

Kamikaze Girls

Home Page      Genres Asian Comics  

Reviewed by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H

Cast

Kyoko Fukada Momoko
Anna Tsuchiya Ichigo
Directed by Tetsuya Nakashima. A female buddy film/pop culture adventure. unrated. Running time: 102 minutes. In Japanese with English sub-titles.

"Kamikaze Girls" is an odd fashion adventure about two girls who develop an unlikely friendship, which crosses subculture lines. Momoko is an ultra feminine fashion fanatic and Ichigo is a gruff, macho biker girl.

"Kamikaze Girls" is based on a popular comic series, which will be translated into English in 2006.

It won a truck load of awards. The Japanese academy gave the film’s star, Kyoko Fukada (she plays Momoko), its best actress award, and they gave her co-star, Anna Tsuchiya, the best supporting actress award.

Momoko is a very troubled fifteen-year-old. Her mom ran off with a gynecologist, and she even kissed him while she was delivering Momoko. So Momoko ends up living with her senile grandparent.

Momoko seems to connect more with clothes than people, and she has a very distinctive fashion sense. She dresses in the Lolita style, which is popular in some parts of Japan. She vamps and struts around in a frilly Bo Peep style dress. It’s supposed to be sexy, but it’s completely ridiculous.

Addicted to clothes, Momoko even resorts to stealing to support her growing habit. Eventually she starts supporting herself by selling fake Versace fashions over the Internet.

One of her customers is a gruff biker named Ichiko. She belongs to a female only gang called the Ponytails, but Ichiko doesn’t completely fit into the group, and of course she eventually gets into a cat fight with the leader.

Ichiko constantly snarls, spits, and talks in an aggressive manner. Her character reminded me of Tura Satana’s character n "Faster Pussycat Kill Kill," but the actress Anna Tsuchiya lacks Satana’s charisma.

The film tries to be a Japanese riot girl version of "Thelma and Louise" but it loses momentum fairly early.

"Kamikaze Girls" is only recommended for fashion aficionados and fans of Japanese comics. It’s colorful and visually interesting, but it’s utterly lacking in substance.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com

The Gospel

Home Page      Genres Music African American  

"THE GOSPEL" is about a young singer who turns his back on God and his father’s church when tragedy strikes. He returns years later to find the once powerful congregation in disarray. With his childhood nemesis creating a “new vision” for the church, he is forced to deal with family turmoil, career suicide and relationship issues that send him on a collision course with redemption or destruction.

"THE GOSPEL" stars Boris Kodjoe, Idris Elba, Nona Gaye, Clifton Powell, Aloma Wright, Donnie McClurkin, Omar Gooding, Tamyra Gray, Hezekiah Walker, Keshia Knight Pulliam.

For reviews, please click here.

Two for the Money

Home Page      Genres Sports    

Review by Mack Bates
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H

Cast

Al Pacino Walter Abrams
Matthew McConaughey Brandon Lang
Rene Russo Toni Abrams
Armand Assante Novian
Jeremy Piven Jerry Sykes
Jaime King Alexandria
Gedde Watanabe Milton
Carly Pope Tammy
Directed by D.J. Caruso. Written by Dan Gilroy. Produced by James G. Robinson and Jay Cohen. Genre: Drama. Rated R (for pervasive language, a scene of sexuality, and a violent act). Universal Pictures 125 minutes.

Place your bets here

If the amount of sweat visible onscreen served as the litmus test for acting talent, Matthew McConaughey’s incessant perspiration in "Two for the Money" would rival Tom Cruise’s in "The Firm" as one of the greatest acting achievements in recent cinematic history.

That said, "Two for the Money" is a better-than-expected parable — inspired by actual events — about the power and scope corruption can wield, anchored by strong performances from leads Al Pacino, Matthew McConaughey (sweat notwithstanding) and Rene Russo (as luminous as ever), under D.J. Caruso’s ("Taking Lives") assured direction.

Tautly written by Russo’s husband, Dan Gilroy ("Dolores Claiborne" and "Freejack"), "Two for the Money" is set in the world of high stakes sports gambling, where a guy can lose a lot more than his shirt.

Based in New York, one of the 49 states where betting on sports is illegal, Walter Abrams (Al Pacino), a renowned betting advisor recruits Las Vegas native Brandon Lang (Matthew McConaughey), a former college football star sidelined by an injury years earlier, to join his sports advising firm. Brandon’s talent for predicting who’ll triumph during a pigskin match surpasses, if not exceeds, his talents on the field, which attracts Walter’s interest.

Yet before Walter closes the deal, he sends Brandon to meet Toni (Rene Russo), Walter’s right hand woman and personal "BS detector," so she can get the skinny on him. Brandon wins over Toni and lands the job despite putting the moves on her prior to knowing she also happens to be Walter’s wife. Once they’re in business together, Walter takes Brandon under his wing and makes him his prized protégé, to the chagrin of some of the other advisors, namely Jerry Sykes (Jeremy Piven of HBO’s "Entourage"). Once the pixie dust starts to fade away and both men bite off more than they can chew, that’s when this parable kicks into high gear and takes us into some pretty dark places where hard truths are learned and loyalties are tested.

Oscar winner Pacino is in the midst of a welcome late-career renaissance thanks to his critically lauded work as the infamous Roy Cohn in the multiple Emmy honored HBO television miniseries "Angels in America." Not to mention his sly turn as Shylock in last year’s film version of Shakespeare’s "Merchant of Venice." To see a reinvigorated Pacino command the screen with seemingly effortless skill, minus the histrionic gluttony that until recently began to saturate his work, is a wondrous thing.

Over the past 15 years or so, with a few exceptions like "Frankie & Johnny," "Heat" and his Oscar-nominated turn as Ricky Roma in "Glengarry Glen Ross," Pacino has hammed his way through any number of roles and blown his lesser co-stars off the screen. So it’s a testament to his new resolve to dial it down and keep it real and their own talents that McConaughey and Russo shine in the film as well.

While Pacino is the heart of "Two for the Money," Rene Russo lays claim to its soul. Her revelatory performance is the yen to Pacino’s yang: when she’s forced to go a couple of rounds with Pacino, not only does she score, she hits it out of the park. Part of what has sustained their marriage is Toni’s willingness to be Walter’s moral compass both personally and professionally.

Without her love and support and occasional reality checks, his actions wouldn’t have the zing, much less the panache that endears him to us despite his flaws. Walter may man the wheels, but it’s Toni who gives him direction and a destination to arrive at. It’s a role that gives Russo the opportunity to stretch as an actor much the same way her two previous career high points did: "Tin Cup" opposite Kevin Costner and the 1999 remake of "The Thomas Crown Affair," with Pierce Brosnan.

Mack Bates © 2005

mack@reelmoviecritic.com


Waiting

Home Page      Genres      

 "WAITING" is a comedy about frustrated waiters, stingy tippers and dicey food, as young employees battling boredom at Shenanigan's, a generic chain restaurant.  A waiter for four years since high school, Dean (Justin Long) has never questioned his job at Shenanigan's. But when he learns that Chett, a high school classmate, now has a lucrative career in electrical engineering, he's thrown into turmoil about his dead-end life.

Dean's friend Monty (Ryan Reynolds) is in exactly the same boat, but he couldn't care less. More concerned with partying, Monty is put in charge of training Mitch (John Francis Daley), a shy new employee.  Over the course of one chaotic shift, Mitch gets to know the rest of Shenanigan's quirky staff: Monty's tough-talking ex-girlfriend, Serena (Anna Faris), Shenanigan's over-zealous manager, Dan (David Koechner), and head cook Raddimus (Luis Guzman), who's obsessed with a senseless staff-wide competition known only as "The Game"...   

"WAITING" stars Ryan Reynolds, Anna Faris and Justin Long and is directed by Rob McKittrick.

For reviews, please click here.

Stormy Waters

Home Page      Genres      

Stormy Waters (Remorques)

Review by Shelley Cameron
for Reel Movie Critic

ê ê ê ½

Cast

Jean Gabin Le capitaine André Laurent
Madeleine Renaud Yvonne Laurent
Michèle Morgan Catherine
Directed by Jean Grémillon. Drama. Not Rated. 1941Running time: 81 minutes. In French with English subtitles.

Sirens of the sea

One of the joys of being a film buff is seeing a rarely-screened little gem for the first time, just when you begin to think you’ve pretty much seen most of the surviving films that are worth seeing from the first 50 or 60 years of moving making. You’ve enjoyed all the celebrated black and white memorable masterpieces, Russian silents, classic Hollywood, European and Japanese greats, small or grand. Such gems are among the selections in the series of French Cinema of the Occupation at Chicago’s Gene Siskel Film Center, playing through September 29. In addition to the magnificent Children of Paradise, the series includes the less well known Douce, and Remorques.

One of these little treasures is Stormy Waters (Remorques), with Jean Gabin at his best playing Andre Laurent, captain of the tugboat Cyclone. Begun in 1939, shelved for two years, and finished during the occupation, if a more somber mood of those bleak years in France inserted itself into the final film finished in 1941, from the distance of 64 years, it is transparent. The tale is one full of simple humanity about men, women and the concerns of love, infidelity, and fear that complicate their lives. For Laurent’s wife, Yvonne (Madeleine Renaud), one rival for his affection perpetually on the horizon is the sea itself. Another is Catherine (Michèle Morgan), a woman Laurent rescues from a storm.

Laurent, his close knit crew, their wives and sweethearts share an understanding of the life of a sailor. The opening scene at the wedding of one of the men reveals the unsentimental, sturdy harmony among the group. The unpretentious happy wedding banquet turns somber when a sudden storm rocks the sky and the crew is called to answer an SOS from a ship in trouble. The rescue is hampered by the greedy machinations of the threatened ship’s captain to save the cargo without keeping his bargain to share the save with the Cyclone. It is further complicated by the presence on board of the captain’s wife and her risky attempt to escape her brutal husband. The visuals of the storm at sea as the tug, the freighter and the men struggle to outlast the wild waters are riveting and powerfully evocative.

Wounds and all, it is all in a night’s work for Laurent who returns home to a nice dry dinner, but rescuing Catherine brings trouble to the happy marriage of Andre and Yvonne, who has been concealing a heart ailment from her husband. The common theme for all three of the principals is a yearning to live and breathe freely, perhaps a reference to the stifling Vichy government.

Directed by Jean Grémillon from a novel by Roger Vercel, the tightly written drama is steeped in atmosphere, with a wonderful economy of dialog and mise en scène. It lacks any trace of the over-produced superfluities that so often accompany many newer films that serve mainly as distracting embellishments. Though one could certainly find a host of metaphors within the plot for life under German occupation, one need not look for hidden meanings beyond its simple humanity. The print is a fine one with only a few minor scratches.

Shelley Cameron © 2005

Shelley@reelmoviecritic.com

 

I am a Sex Addict

Reviewed by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H

"I am a Sex Addict" is a fairly diverting documentary that occasionally lapses into self indulgence. It was directed and written by the promising film maker, Cayeh Zahedi.

The film is highly autobiographical, and the audience’s reaction may depend upon how well they like the director/narrator. It chronicles how he eventually overcame his unhealthy sex habits, and became more stable and happy

Zahedi narrates the film himself, but he uses actresses to play his girlfriends. He also shows the real girlfriends that declined to appear in the film as themselves. His narration is sometimes witty and occasionally annoying.

Zahedi is a troubled man who reminds me of the George Costanza character on the "Seinfeld" show because he has the habit of sabotaging all his romantic relationships. He is painfully honest, and at one point he admits every lustful thought he has until he drives his wife away. Earlier, he had left the woman he truly loved to make a film on Rimbaud in France with a suicidal psychopath. Of course, once he gets to France, he can’t raise the funds to make the film.

Zanedi was a philosophy major before he made films, and he tries to justify his philandering and his lack of commitment on ethical grounds. He argues that marriage is a bourgeois construct that reinforces the power structure, and no person should possess another. This allows him to see people on the side, but he is hurt when his lovers or wives do the same.

He also has a fetish for prostitutes, and he seems to get more excited by ‘"shopping" for them than actually having sex with them. At one point, he is attracted to a prostitute because she resembles his wife even though he is no longer attracted to his wife.

When his desires become insurmountable, he joins a sex addict self help group, and he treats the audience to a revealing clip of one of the meetings.

Viewers expecting an erotic documentary that will arouse them will be sorely disappointed. The film shows how one man’s bad sexual and relationship habits almost ruin his life. If anything the film will sour viewers on irresponsible sex.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com

 

How to Eat Your Watermelon in White Company (and enjoy it)

Reviewed by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H ½

Cast

"How to Eat Your Watermelon in White Company (and enjoy It)" is an informative and lively documentary about the important African American film maker/Renaissance man, Melvin Van Peebles. The film gets its title from a ridiculous article that offered African Americans tips on how to eat with whites without making waves. The film’s a bit raw, but it compares favorably with "Badassss!" which was also made on the same subject, by Van Peebles’s son, Mario.

It includes generous amount of film clips which still have the power to shock and provoke. The clips are interspersed with revealing interview footage with his son, Mario; Spike Lee; Gordon Parks; "Village Voice" film critic; Elvis Mitchell, and many others.

Van Peebles had a strong drive to succeed, but early on he was an abject failure at everything he tried. He was fired from his streetcar operator job for writing a book about his work experiences. Later, he was denied a promotion when the men from his fellow platoon members reported him for spending time with a Caucasian girl.

But the film is ultimately inspiring. It shows how Van Peebles overcame tremendous obstacles and helped break the artistic racial barriers in the arts. He became a successful novelist, musician, photographer, film maker, play wright, and even a Wall Street broker. He turned all his defeats into opportunities for self improvement.

The film offers some insight into why Van Peebles was such a great deal maker. His tailor father had him go out and sell unclaimed clothing in the streets. If he asked for too much money the older boys might take the clothes and beat him up, and if he asked for too little his dad would beat him. So he was forced to find a compromise that would please everyone, and this lesson served him well in his artistic career.

Van Peebles was in equal parts an artist and a conman. He fakes out a producer when he pretends to lose the alternate ending to "Watermelon Man," so that he could get the ending he favored in the film.

Van Peebles’s boundless energy also was reflected in his private life. He was also extremely promiscuous, and the film shows that he had a different woman lined up for every day of the week.

"How to Eat Your Watermelon in White Company (and enjoy It") should please most film buffs, especially lovers of the blaxploitation genre.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com

 

Poet of the Wastes

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H H

"Poet of the Wastes" is a raw, powerful, and visceral film about a romantic dreamer that works as a street cleaner in Iran. He disobeys orders and begins to get involved in the lives of some of the townspeople.

The look of the film is cheap and the film stock has washed out colors, so it looks like a Neorealist or Dogma 95 film. These characteristics effectively mirror the film’s subject, the economic underbelly of Tehran. It’s as slow moving as an Aki Karismaki film and very little happens. so the power of very little occurrence is magnified tenfold.

The narrator/protagonist tells us some sobering facts. He tells us that there are 3 million unemployed and only 1 out of every 1,000 people has a job. At first he too has trouble finding a job. He applies for a position, and the employer asks him intrusive questions, like how many times does he pray a day. He is turned down because he can’t commit politically (some may make the same accusation of the maker of this film.)

He eventually gets a coveted street cleaner job and he spends his time taking away garbage. Because of his job, he seems to develop a love for the refuse in society including a forlorn hermit poet with a long beard, and a sad woman mourning the death of her fiancé.

The poet speaks in mostly aphoristic statements reminiscent of the ones uttered by the lead character in "Being There." He delivers all the most memorable lines in the film.

His fatalistic view of his role in society is summed up when he says: "I am a cow who cannot flee the country. He stays so they can behead him in honor of his fellow citizens." He also says: "Cows consume grass and produce milk. Poets consume newspapers and produce poems." Finally, he suggests that in order to become a poet one must plant his or her feet in the ground.

The lonely woman continually gets turned down for a visa, and she is on the verge of starvation. To cheer her up, the street cleaner sends one of the hermit’s poems to her-- pretending to be an admiring friend of her husband’s.

The film does an exemplary job of depicting the grim social realities in Tehran, and the characters are unforgettable. It also has one of the most gorgeous/ugly conclusions within memory.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com


 

Lola Montes

Reviewed by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H

Cast

Martine Carol Lola Montes
Peter Ustinov Circus Master
Directed by Max Ophuls. A period picture/biopic. Running time: 110 minutes. In French and German with English sub-titles.

"Lola Montes" is being shown at the 41st Chicago International Film Festival at 6:30 on 10/18 at the Landmark Century Theater.

"Lola Montes" is a dreary, snail-paced historical biopic, about the rise and fall of a famous courtesan in 19th century France.

Considered a masterpiece by many critics, and according to the Chicago Film Festival brochure, Andrew Sarris called "Lola Montes" the greatest movie ever made.

But the film has many dull spots, and it is vastly overrated. It’s the only "classic" that put me to sleep twice.

The film was directed by the respected filmmaker Max Ophuls, who also did the vastly superior but more obscure "Earrings of Madame de…." "Lola Montes was his last film, and it was recut as he lay dying because the investors thought a shorter version would be less likely to bomb at the box office. When the film was originally released in 1955, it lost a large sum of money in it’s first run.

The film begins with Lola Montes being humiliated in a circus, which is run by the peppy but sadistic Peter Ustinov. Circus goers are encouraged to ask any questions they want of the famous courtesan.

Eventually we see huge chunks of her scandal filled life depicted on screen, and it turns out she is responsible for the fall of many powerful men. We see her affairs with King Ludwig of Bavaria, and even the composer, Frank Liszt.

The film’s biggest problem lies in the casting. Lead actress, Martine Carol is fine in the lead role in the early parts of the film, but she looks about ten years too old in the flashbacks to Lola’s youth. She lacks the otherworldly allure of Marline Dietrich, the cool eroticism of Greta Garbo, or the gutsy charm of Barbara Stanwyck.

As a result, it’s impossible to understand what all the fuss is about or why every other man on the planet is dying to be with Lola. Without a charismatic actress in the lead, there is a big void in the center of the film.

"Lola Montes" is an occasionally interesting curio, but it is not a classic in any of its cuts. The original version of "The Blue Angel" and "Pandora’s Box" accomplish all the goals of this film much better.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com


 

The Conformist

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H H

Cast

Jean-Louis Trintignant Marcello Clerici
Stefania Sandrelli Giulia
Dominque Sanda Anna Quadri
Directed by Bernardo Bertolucci. A political thriller/art film. Rated R. Paramount Pictures. Running time: 115 minutes. In Italian with English sub-titles.
Home Page      Genres Italy Politics  

"The Conformist" is an intoxicatingly beautiful and highly intelligent political film about a young Italian named Marcello. He works for the fascist secret police in World War II era Italy, and they order him to assassinate his former college professor.

The two parted ways when Marcello quit his thesis, which dealt with Plato’s "Allegory of the Cave." This is highly significant because Marcello is as short sighted as the men in the allegory that believe the shadows constitute reality. Apparently Marcello never learned the allegory’s lesson.

Based on a celebrated novel by Alberto Moravia, this film version follows the novel’s basic plotline, but it is much less linear. The film even has flashbacks within flashbacks.

"The Conformist" is somewhat minimalist and it does away with many stock and trade flashback devices, such as fade-ins, fade-outs, and voice over narration.

A noted and respected scholar, Jessi Klein wrote that the early scenes the film "…not only lack causal and chronological coherence, they operate by condensation, displacement, projections and doubling—all techniques of what Freud termed latent dream work."

The brilliant Vittorio Storraro (he later shot "The Godfather," 1972) provides some of the best ever cinematography. Overall, "The Conformist" is Bernardo Bertolucci’s strongest and most fully realized work.

Along with Marco Bellocchio and Lina Wertmuller, Bertolucci was part of a new generation of film makers that emerged in Italy in the 1960’s. Most of them were radical leftists, and they avoided the wide eyed sentimentality of their predecessors: Federico Fellini and Vittorio De Sica.

Early in his career, Bertolucci was highly influenced by the ideas of Karl Marx and Sigmund Freud.

His early films (such as "Before the Revolution" (1965), "Partner" (1968), "The Conformist" (1970), and "The Last Tango in Paris" (1973), are marked by political intrigue, and their protagonists tend to have deep seated psychosexual problems.

In "The Conformist" Marcello Clerici (Jean-Louis Trintignant), was traumatized by a boyhood sexual encounter with a depraved man. Also, his father went insane from syphilis. Marcello tries to forget his past by becoming a total bourgeois conformist.

One of the ways he tries to join society is by marrying the ravishing but empty headed Giulia (well played by Stefania Sandrelli who was in four of Bertolucci’s films). He seems to have no strong feelings for her one way or another, but he thinks marrying her will make him "respectable."

Marcello travels to Paris with her, to assassinate his former philosophy professor, who happens to have the same address as Bertolucci’s real life cinematic mentor, Jean-Luc Godard. Interestingly enough, this film was Bertolucci’s least Godardian movie up until that point, and it conforms to more of an Orson Welles influenced style.

In Paris, Marcello immediately falls for the professor’s sexy, bi-sexual wife, Anna (Dominique Sanda). At first she resists his advances, but eventually she becomes attracted to him. The scenario becomes more complicated when a sexual spark also ignites between Giulia and Ana during a provocative tango. The dance seems to be one of the few places where the norms in a fascist society can be violated. This is justifiably one of the most celebrated and written about dance sequences in film history; and it was even used for the cover photo for Peter Bondarella’s seminal film book "Italian Cinema: from Neorealism to the Present."

The violence filled finale of the film, which takes place in the Coliseum on the night of Mussolini’s fall, packs a punch.

The conclusion and the film as a whole are hypnotic and unforgettable. "The Conformist" is a quintessential ‘70s art film, and it holds up better than almost all of the other films of its era.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com


Entre Ses Mains

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H ½

Home Page      Genres      

"Entre Ses Mains" is a slow moving, substandard murder mystery, made in France. The title translates to "In His Hands," which is apt since it’s about a veterinarian who may also be a killer.

This predictable, cliché filled film was directed and co-written by Anne Fontaine, who played a memorable role in the delightfully lusty 70’s romance, "Les Cousins." Funnyman Benoit Poelvorde fails to impress in the role of the suspected killer.

"Entre Ses Mains" plays like a third rate imitation of Claude Chabrol’s "Le Boucher," minus the suspense and great acting. Both films are about weak-willed women that may be dating murderers.

The film begins when a distinguished looking, seemingly respectable veterinarian named Laurent (Benoit Poelvoorde) pays a visit to an insurance office to file a claim. He meets a pretty but bland insurance assessor named Claire (Isabelle Carre). She becomes attracted to him for reasons that may escape the audience. She has a caring, handsome husband, and Laurent is utterly without charm. Perhaps she is one of those people who must sabotage their own happiness.

It turns out that Laurent is a rakish womanizer, he even has a rendezvous with Claire’s best friend, Valerie, behind Claire’s back. It comes as no surprise when something terrible happens to her. In fact very little in the film is surprising. I basically had the whole thing figured out in the first five minutes.

Claire learns that there is a serial killer roaming around town stabbing women to death. She begins to suspect that her mysterious lover may be the culprit, and the film crawls like slug toward its unsatisfying conclusion.

It’s difficult to get involved in the film’s plot when none of the characters are likeable or well developed. The only character that the audience may feel some sympathy for is Claire’s husband, and he’s on screen for about three minutes.

Part of the problem with the film is that the music does nothing to heighten the film’s paranoid, threatening atmosphere. It’s too bad that the "Vertigo" score composer, Bernard Hermann is long deceased. He might have been the only composer that could’ve pumped a little life into this still born mystery.

This may be one of the weakest and least involving films to play at this year’s Chicago International Film Festival.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com

 

Return of the Living Dead

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

3 Stars

Cast

Clu Gulager Burt
James Karen Frank
Thom Matthews Ernie
Linnea Quigley Trash
Directed by Dan O’Bannon. A horror film. Rated R (for violence, language and some sexuality). Orion. Running time: 91 minutes
Home Page      Genres  Horror    

"Return of the Living Dead" is a surprisingly effective and stylish rip-off of George Romero’s zombie films. It deftly combines repulsive gore with riveting action and sly humor. A chemical accident unleashes a plague of zombies, and a group of creatively dressed punk/new wave fans, a few preppies, and some "normal" adults fight against the growing zombie hordes.

"Return of the Living Dead" differs from "Night of the Living Dead," because the living dead can run fast, they possess greater than mortal strength, and they occasionally use their intelligence to trap the living. Also, they only eat brains because it relieves the pain of being dead. The cannibalism scenes in the film are convincing looking because the film uses real cow brains.

The seminal 80s horror film will be shown at the Music Box on October 16 at 3:05 as part of the Music Box Massacre, which will feature 24 hours of horror films including the classic silent vampire film, "Nosferatu" and the premier of the new Japanese terror flick, "Pulse."

There will also be a Halloween costume contest, and an appearance by the popular horror host, Count Midnight. Appropriately enough the excellent local punk/horror band Mucus will also play live at the festival at 2:30 p.m on October 16. Tickets can be purchased for $20 in advance at www.ticketweb.com or for $24 at the Music Box on the day of the festival. For more info and a complete schedule go to http://movieside.neweyefilms.com.

"Return of the Living Dead" is one of the festival highlights. It was originally released in 1985, and it was so successful that it spawned its own cycle of zombie films, the best of them, "Return of the Living Dead III" was famously panned by former mayor Ed Koch in a film review that was part of a TV talk show.

"Return of the Living Dead" starts out announcing that the events of "Night of the Living Dead" actually happened, but they were fictionalized to avoid a lawsuit. The real zombies were created by a chemical spill, and the chemical containers were accidentally sent to a business that provides corpses for the medical establishment.

Of course a pair of numbskulls (hilariously played by Thom Matthews and James Karen) accidentally release the gas. One of the cadavers comes back so the men cremate him, which releases the gas into the air. The man who helps them cremate the corpse listens to German music, and he may be a Nazi. An acidy rain spreads the gas into the graves at the aptly named Resurrection Cemetery.

Some punk and new wave fans are partying in the cemetery waiting for their friend Freddy--oblivious to the fact that they are about to become zombie food. An exhibitionistic female punk named Trash (Linnea Quigley) does a strip tease. She shares her necrophilia fantasies with the group, but she gets more than she bargained for. Linnea Quigley later went on to become the supreme scream queen in the ‘80s. She was always much better than her films

This film includes some blistering punk tunes, which works ideally in the film. I particularly liked Rocky Ericson’s "Burn the Flames’" when a noble zombie cremates himself. The soundtrack also includes songs by The Cramps, The Damned, and the Flesheaters.

"Return of the Living Dead" does not break new ground, and it is not nearly as thoughtful as the recent George Romero film, "Land of the Dead." But it is well directed, and wonderfully campy, so it richly deserves its fervid cult following.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com

 

Touch the Sound

Review by Shelley Cameron
for Reel Movie Critic

ê ê ½

Cast

Evelyn Glennie Fred Firth
Directed by Thomas Riedelsheimer. Documentary. Not Rated.
Running time: 99 minutes.

Deaf musician develops her sixth sense.

Home Page      Genres      

From the director of Rivers and Tides, this foray into capturing the essence of something as intangible and transitory as sound, though not quite as compelling, is successful as a fascinating look at one woman and the processes she uses to access sound. Thomas Riedelsheimer follows Scot musician Evelyn Glennie performing and creating music that she experiences largely through her sense of touch. A childhood hearing loss claimed most of her ability to hear normally through the eardrums. That loss is not what this film is about. An accomplished world renowned percussionist, she is revealed to be gifted through all her senses rather than limited by just one. Her additional gifts include her drive to communicate how the sound might be touched by anyone, hearing, sighted or otherwise.

In the award winning Rivers and Tides, Goldsworthy’s art captured time on film, the intense visual nature of his work being the perfect partner for the medium. Glennie’s artistry is a different animal and takes a bit more coaxing to get over to the audience, but the reward is worth the effort. Through a myriad of sounds at the outset – drums, traffic, wheels, heartbeats, construction, tap dancing, footsteps, wrecking ball, raindrops, ocean waves, cracking ice, wind and silence, Riedelsheimer hooks us into listening with more care to everything that follows. Through performances, improvisational recording sessions and considerable first person narration from Glennie, her drive to feel sound and live inside the rhythms of the world is illuminated.

One tour of the US takes her to New York’s Grand Central Station where passersby are drawn and held by her unique solo drums. There in the Great Hall, in an abandon factory with its variety of sound-reflective surfaces, in the great outdoors, and throughout the film the camera moves around her in 360 degree turns to add more visual interest. With fellow musician Fred Firth, she makes extraordinary percussive music. Glennie describes in meticulous detail how the whole body can be used to feel and sense the endless variations of rhythm and vibration until we begin to touch the sound with her. Riedelsheimer’s focus is on Glennie’s reverberations and he stays away from her hearing loss and personal life. Though not totally successful at involving the audience in her experience, it’s not for lack of trying. By nature, the difficult task of crystallizing the essence of a fleeting sound through a visual medium is paradoxical.

In the end, one is left with a greater appreciation of sound and certainly a greater understanding of how Evelyn Glennie’s boundless energy and supportive family allowed her to forge new musical territory.

Shelley Cameron © 2005

Shelley@reelmoviecritic.com


 

Innocence

Review by Vittorio J. Carlifor Reel Movie Critic

H H H ½

Home Page      Genres      

"Innocence" is a hypnotic and atmospheric French coming of age drama that tells the story of a new pupil in a repressive all girls’ school. Nothing terrible happens in the beginning, but the school has a sinister atmosphere. We never find out exactly where and when the film takes place, and for all we know it could be hell.

"Innocence" (2005) should not be confused with the superb Paul Cox film from 2000 with the same title, which is about elder lovers having an affair.

Directed by Lucille Hadzihalilovic, who is the current paramour of Gaspar Noe, the director of the even more disturbing "Irreversible," "Innocence" is shot by Benoit Debie, the cinematographer who also did "Irreversible." The lush cinematography of "Innocence" is as ripe and gorgeous looking as "Walkabout" or "Picnic at Hanging Rock." All three films do a great job of creating an aura of sexual repression and foreboding evil.

The film opens with swirl of colors and some languid water imagery (the water imagery is repeated in the end.) The opening makes the audience falsely feel as if "Innocence" will be a safe and comforting film.

This is followed by a terrifically disturbing sequence in which a living six-year-old, Iris (Zoë Auclair) is taken out of a coffin. She is placed in a private school in the woods with no visitation and many stringent rules.

The girls spend much of their time exercising and the ballet teacher is fairly strict and she frequently speaks cryptically. At one point she tells the girls: "You’re ugly little caterpillars, you have to work hard—sadly not all caterpillars become butterflies."

Most of the faculty members practice a not so subtle form of mind control on the students. The girls are told that obedience is the only path that leads to happiness. The girls are also ordered that they must not walk down certain paths or go out at night.

But the oldest girl in each of the five houses disappears all night, and she doesn’t tell where she goes. Viewers may suspect that some kind of abuse is going on, but we can’t be sure what form it takes. Iris looks up to the older Bianca who is one of the disappearing girls.

One scene of shocking cruelty has sado masochistic overtones. At one point, an older girl is tickled then beats a younger girl for displeasing her. This is perhaps one of the most disturbing sequences of youthful evil since "The Bad Seed."

"Innocence" is an excellent portrayal of imprisonment disguised as education, and it would make a fine companion piece to the even more powerful "The Magdalene Sisters," which explored a similar subject.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com


 

Once You're Born You Can No Longer Hide

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H

Home Page      Genres      

Marco Tulio Giordana, the acclaimed director of the three-hour plus epic, "The Best of Youth," also brings us "Once You're Born You Can No Longer Hide." Here Giordana’s direction is spare and economical. Although, it's a work of fiction, the film was shot in quasi cinema verite style. "Once You're Born You Can No Longer Hide" is a competent, socially conscious drama about immigration in modern day Italy.

The film breaks down into two sections. The first part depicts the lifestyles of the Italian upper class, and the second half deals with the newer multi-ethnic lower class Italian immigrants.

Bruno and Lucia are a well off couple that owns a factory in Brescia, a city in Northern Italy. Their ten-year-old son Sandro encounters an African man trying to use a phone in a public booth. When Sandro tries to explain that the phone is out of order, the African screams out a phrase in his native tongue. We later find out the phrase means, "Once you're born, you can no longer hide."

The father and son vacation on a boat off the coast of Greece. But the boy gets sleepy and falls off the edge of the boat. It takes hours before Bruno even notices his absence. The son's disappearance sends his mother, Lucia into a deep depression.

Sandro, however, narrowly escapes death. He is picked up by a ship filled with immigrants coming to Italy. He gets to see the deplorable conditions immigrants live in. The boat is overcrowded, and people defecate in public. He also meets an exotic prepubescent girl who has the habit of prostituting herself.

The boy has an epiphany when he becomes aware of the plight of the underclass. He tries to get his parents to adopt two of the immigrant kids but this doesn't go as planned.

This film differs from the '50s Neorealist films because no effort is made to romanticize the working class. They are not long suffering martyrs in this film but ordinary flawed people.

"Once You're Born You Can No Longer Hide" is a reasonably interesting and solid look at immigration related problems in modern Europe. But the film lacks style, and it could have done more with its subject matter.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com

 

Stoned

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H 1/2

Home Page      Genres      

"Stoned" is a lackluster and rather demoralizing portrait of Brian Jones, the late guitarist for the Rolling Stones. The story is told in a non-linear fashion with many flashbacks.

It focuses on his hedonism and mostly ignores his considerable musical accomplishments—including his breakthroughs in world music and using exotic instruments. Jones comes off as just another burned out rock and roll psycho.

The film features a charisma-less lead performance by Leo Gregory. Gregory looks a little like Jones, but he usually fails to capture his charm or creativity.

Loosely based on accounts of Jones’s life by Neal Purvis and Robert Wade, the film was in development for 10 years but it was not worth the time and trouble.

In the film, Jones spends most of his time in isolation with his comely Swedish girlfriend, Anna (well played by Tuva Novotny). Their relationship is brutal and laced with sado masochism. At one point, she even complains that he can’t get excited unless he’s hitting her.

There are also flashbacks depicting Jones’s relationship with the witch/society woman Anita Pallenberg (Monet Mazur), who dumped Jones for fellow Stone, Keith Richards.

The film suffers immensely because it contains no Rolling Stones recordings, so we never get to see Jones work his magic in the studio. Instead we get some tunes that the Stones later recorded, but here are earlier versions by other artists, like Robert Johnson. We also hear some covers of songs associated with the Rolling Stones by the Bees and the White Stripes. Predictably, when Jones does acid, Jefferson Airplane’s "White Rabbit" blares in the background.

After the film is over, viewers will probably be far less interested in Brian Jones than before. "Stoned" is even more boring and repellant than "Last Days," Gus Van Sant’s recent deconstruction of Kurt Cobain.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com


Ushpizin

Home Page      Genres Jewish    

Director:  Gidi Dar
In Hebrew with English subtitles
Rating:  PG-13 for mild thematic elements

Winner of the 2004 Best Actor award at the 2004 Israeli Film Academy for writer-star Shuli Rand, director Gidi Dar’s film, Ushpizin (roughly translated to “holy guests”), is a revelatory - and humorous - look at the daily lives of ultra-Orthodox Jews learning, living, and loving in modern-day Israel. Disarmingly funny, the film also startles in its universality, depicting members of the ultra-Orthodox community in scenes of ordinary living, drinking, smoking, dancing, arguing, reconciling, listening to popular music, and grappling with their faith.  

In its ultimately celebratory, fable-like quality, Ushpizin is a completely unique moviegoing experience: equal parts Isaac Bashevis Singer and It’s A Wonderful Life.

Loggerheads

Home Page      Genres No Carolina Family  

Director Tim Kirkman (DEAR JESSE) returns to his native North Carolina to weave a tender and thought-provoking drama about the longing for family and the challenges of keeping one together. Three stories, all centered around Mother`s Day, intertwine to tell a singular tale about the strength of the human heart and the love of family. Tall and world-weary, a handsome young gay drifter, Mark (Kip Pardue), arrives in a small coastal town to watch over the endangered loggerhead turtles that nest there. He finds a kind smile and a bit of solace in a local motel manager, George (Michael Kelly). Grace (Bonnie Hunt), a Southern woman approaching middle age but still lost in the world, returns to her hometown and a domineering mother to search for the son she gave up for adoption long ago. Elizabeth (Tess Harper), the tight-lipped wife of a conservative, small-town preacher, must decide whether to break with both her husband and the church to do right by her son. Anchored by nuanced and inspired performances, a dramatically mature script, and exquisite landscape cinematography, Loggerheads beautifully depicts the lives of characters who are ultimately driven by their hearts and souls to deal with the repercussions of their past actions and to make things right again, no matter how difficult.

OFFICIAL SELECTION - 2005 SUNDANCE FILM FESTIVAL, DRAMATIC COMPETITION

WINNER - BEST FEATURE FILM, GRAND JURY PRIZE, OUTFEST 2005 (LA)

WINNER - BEST FEATURE FILM (AUDIENCE AWARD), 2005 NASHVILLE FILM FESTIVAL

WINNER - BEST FEATURE FILM (AUDIENCE AWARD) - 2005 FLORIDA FILM FESTIVAL

Pale Eyes

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H

Home Page      Genres      

"Pale Eyes" is a touching, well developed, and highly romantic film made in France. It’s a dysfunctional family drama about a mentally unstable woman who struggles to achieve a small measure of freedom.

It is the second film directed by Jerome Bonnel, who received critical acclaim for his debut, "Le Chignon d’Olga (2002)," which also starred Natalie Boutefeu." "Pale Eyes" is bound to get some positive notices as well.

The film is a modern Cinderella tale with the Fanny character in the role of the abused young woman. Her daughter-in-law behaves like a wicked step-sister, and a German hermit who lives in the forest serves as the film’s unlikely Prince Charming.

Natalie Boutefeu gives a convincing performance in the lead role. She is able to perfectly simulate wild mood swings, and schizophrenic behavior. Fanny is a sensitive and lonely young woman who spends most of her time listening to music. She suffers from delusions, and she is occasionally violent. She is basically loveable but living with her would try anyone’s patience.

She lives with her brother, Gabriel, and her catty sister-in-law, Cécile, and Fanny’s presence clearly puts a strain on the marriage. Fanny gets along fine with her quiet and somewhat submissive brother. But one day, she gets into a violent tussle with the adulterous Cécile. Fanny ends up pulling her hair and physically accosting her.

Gabriel doesn’t know what to do. He locks Fanny in her room, and considers returning her to a mental hospital. But Fanny escapes in the family car. She looks for her father’s grave, and ends up finding romantic adventure.

The screener that I was given flashed "Europacorp Property" throughthe center of every scene, who may encourage some critics to see the film as intellectual property rather than art.

"Pale Eyes" is a fairly convincing depiction of mental illness, and it’s filled with effective, quiet moments that sneak up on you. It also has a wonderfully tender and thrilling conclusion. The film has some slow parts, but it’s definitely worth seeing.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com

 

Johanna

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H

Home Page      Genres      

"Johanna" is one of the strangest films I’ve seen all year. It’s a musical version of the "Joan of Arc" story in which the main character is a former crack addicted prostitute. It’s sure to offend many people, but it is fairly involving.

The film was made by the Hungarian director Kornel Mundruczo. Some of the ideas in "Johanna" previously appeared in his 24 minute short "Joan of Arc of the Night Bus." That film depicts the first scene of an opera triptych, and it’s about a modern day Joan of Arc who participates in staged accidents.

"Johanna" is quite a bit less profound and sublime than Carl Dreyer’s "The Passion of Joan of Arc" and Robert Bresson’s "The Trial of Joan of Arc." But it sure beats "The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc," Luc Besson’s worst cinematic debacle.

But "Johanna" is most similar to the Lars Von Trier film, "Dancer in the Dark." Both films are wacky/tragic musicals about martyred women destroyed by unfeeling societies that turn against them. "Johanna" even has a low budget look similar to "Dancer in the Dark," but it is not nearly as fresh or groundbreaking as the Von Trier film. Also, "Dancer in the Dark" has far better singing and music.

But "Johanna" benefits greatly from a low key, natural performance by Orsolya Toth in the lead role, who somehow manages to radiate sensuality and holiness at the same time.

Joan survives a terrible traffic accident, and she is admitted as a patient in a Budapest hospital. Her doctor learns that she is a drug addict and prostitute. He takes pity on her, and gives her a job as a nurse. Since she has no medical training, this plot development is completely ludicrous. The doctor keeps looking at her cleavage, and he seems obsessed with her.

After Johanna awakens from a coma, she finds that she can cure male patients by sleeping with them. Of course the doctor gets jealous, and he organizes the medical establishment against her.

Despite the intriguing plot, the film was sometimes difficult to sit through. It was so badly subtitled, that it was often difficult to read what the characters were saying.

"Johanna" is by no means the quintessential Joan of Arc film, but it is fairly creative and engrossing. It does a good job of presenting a novel twist on a classic story.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com


Capote (R) êêê½

Home Page      Genres      

 On November 15, 1959 the brutal murder of a family in a small Kansas town sent shock waves through the nation. One-of-a-kind author Truman Capote was sent to Kansas to pen an article about the crimes for The New Yorker magazine. He ended up writing one of the most celebrated books of the century.

The film follows Truman Capote (Philip Seymour Hoffman) on his odyssey to create the landmark bestseller "In Cold Blood." With style and caustic wit – and his friend Harper Lee (Catherine Keener) in tow – Capote attempts to charm the locals and work his way into the story behind the murders. He’s soon shocked, however, to find himself forming a friendship with one of the killers, Perry Smith (Clifton Collins, Jr.). As the book nears completion and execution day approaches, Capote finds himself torn in directions he never anticipated and is forever changed by his experiences.

The movie provides insight into the minds of cold-blooded killers as well as how those in legitimate professions are amoral users of people who mistook them as friends.
 

George O. Singleton © 2005

george@reelmoviecritic.com pam@reelmoviecritic.com

Doom

Home Page      Genres Sci Fi    

coming reel soon

G

Home Page      Genres      

 

Andrew Lauren Production presents G, opening nationwide on Friday, October 28th.“G” is a hip-hop romantic drama set against the backdrop of the Hamptons. The film stars Richard T. Jones (“Judging Amy”), Andre Royo (“The Wire”) and Blair Underwood (“LA Law”, “Sex and the City”). Hip-hop mogul Summer G falls for a middle- to upper-class sister while in college. After she rejects him for a fellow social climber, Summer G spends ten years building a Hip Hop empire, then moves to the Hamptons where he finds the object of his affections. This new form of Bourgeois Hip Hop embodies familiar issues of love, betrayal, and jealously giving universal thematic understanding and sympathy for the characters. ‘G’ presents a side of hip-hop life never before investigated, executing racial and socioeconomic devices that purge the Hamptons of its white-bread communal exclusivity.

Domino (R) ê

Home Page      Genres True Story Feminism  
Director Tony Scott ("Man on Fire") presents a mix of gritty action, at times sharp comedy and outstanding visuals in a movie about a former model who rejects her privileged Beverly Hills life to become a bounty hunter.

An action packed picture, with the promise of twists, we were expecting a far better film than "Domino" turned out to be. It looks good, but you never really care about the characters; possibly because they are such foul-mouth, low life’s for one thing. Another is that after a bit, the profanity crosses over into the vast wasteland of gratuitous obscenities. It’s about this time that the plot starts running in place. The film might have "played" much better if the running time had been closer to 90 rather than 120 minutes (e.g. Red Eye).

Keira Knightley as the ill-fated Domino is the polar opposite of her role as Elizabeth Bennet in "Pride & Prejudice." Please don’t let this performance keep you from seeing "Pride & Prejudice." Mickey Rourke is again decidedly sordid as a scumbag but the best this film can do with respect to any resemblance to "Sin City" is to be a wannabe.

One redeeming aspect of the film is that Mo’Nique (TVs "The Parkers") has a hilarious scene about ethnic classifications on the Jerry Springer show. But the bottom line is that this film is a mess. It’s definitely a movie to skip, not only in the theater but at home as well. It has no redeeming value when it comes to determining how to spend two hours of your life.

George & Pam Singleton © 2005

pam@reelmoviecritic.com or george@reelmoviecritic.com

 

We Are All Fine

Reviewed by Shelley Cameron
for Reel Movie Critic

ê ê ê ½

Cast

Directed by Bizhan Mirbaqeri. Drama / Family. Not rated.Running time: 90 minutes. In Persian with English subtitles.
Home Page      Genres Iran Family  

Uncertainty lingers for the family of an émigré

  Consider the ritual greeting "How are you?" The standard ritual answer is to say everything is fine. Whether around the block or around the world, this convention does not seem to change much and it is often deceptive, intentionally or not. In the first feature film from Iranian director Bizhan Mirbaqeri, this is the preferred response to the question when it comes to the family of eldest son Jimshid via a friend of a friend. Six years after Jimshid left Iran seeking better fortune, a stranger shows up at the door with a message asking that the family make a video to send to him.
Ma hameh khoubim - we are all fine

This fully realized contemporary study reveals as much about the universal nature of families as it does about life in Iran. It is a condensed snapshot of each member individually, of their relationships to each other, and to Jimshid. Not without irony, Jimshid is the one family member who remains almost a complete unknown. For two or three years he wrote and sent money to his mother, father, brother, sister, wife and baby daughter. Then the communication dwindled to nothing and they have had no word from him for over two years.

Happy to hear from his big bro, Jimshid’s younger brother accepts the task of renting a video camera and starts the tape rolling. Taking place mostly in the family home over an unspecified number of days, various members of the family face the camera to give their collective greetings and private messages to the long absent Jimshid. His mother is overjoyed and stages living examples of a happy home front. His father is confused and angry by his long neglect. His skeptical sister is fed up with the role of sole family breadwinner and wants to move on with her own life. Saddest and most moving is his unhappy wife who has been in the limbo of neither wife nor widow since his disappearance. The video project receives mixed and shifting support within the family and it is gradually revealed just how deep an impact his desertion has had.

Leaving plenty unsaid about what new direction Jimshid’s life has taken, the family remains in the dark. Ultimately, it is not about Jimshid, but about the limitations of a closed society where people are not free to simply pick up the phone to call or go in search of a missing member. A few forays into the neighborhood with the video camera are telling about the repressive atmosphere and this fresh idea succeeds in illuminating the underpinnings of family and community.

The shaky handheld camera distinguishes what Jimshid will see on the video from the rest of the film and gives a remarkably accurate sense of this family. Watching the capable cast feels as if we are watching a real household. Showing on October 29 and 30, 2005 as part of the Festival of Films from Iran at the Gene Siskel Film Center, this film belongs in that company of small worthwhile films like Strangers in Good Company, It All Starts Today and so many others where melodramatic events are replaced by authenticity. Such quiet gems are worthy of a much larger audience than they are likely to get.

Shelley Cameron © 2005

Shelley@reelmoviecritic.com

 

Gabrielle

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H

Cast

Gabrielle Hervey Isabelle Huppert
Jean Hervey Pascal Greggory
Directed by Patrice Chereau. A historical drama. unrated. Mars. Running time: 90 minutes. In French with English sub-titles.

"Gabrielle" is an emotionally devastating but overripe drama about a marriage that's falling apart. It has some similarities to "Who's Afraid of Virginia Wolfe" because both stories feature married people that constantly torture their partners. The film also takes aim at the hollowness of bourgeois married life, but it doesn't always hit the target.

The film was directed by Patrice Cherneau, who is probably best known in the United States for "Queen Margot," his lush cinematic adaptation of the Alexander Dumas classic. That film did a fine job of showcasing the full acting range of Isabelle ("Story of Adele H.") Adjani. Gabrielle" was based on the short story "The Return," by Joseph Conrad, the stylistically brilliant writer of "Heart of Darkness."

Gabrielle

"Gabrielle" was screened at both the Venice Film Festival and the Chicago International Film Festival. The Chicago screening was followed by an informative question and answer session with its director.

Sumptuous sets, crisp cinematography, and riveting performances mark "Gabrielle." Daniel Auteuil ("Cache") and Isabelle Huppert ("The Piano Teacher") are often excellent, but Auteuil overacts in some scenes.

Huppert is stunningly beautiful, but for "Gabrielle" she bravely allowed herself to be shot in an extremely unflattering manner. She constantly looks pale and full of pain in the film, which befits her character.

The film begins with a single tracking shot that follows Jean (Auteul) from the train station to his magnificent estate. He finds a letter from his wife announcing that she has left him for another man. The content of the letter is revealed to the audience in an interesting manner. We see phrases from the letter on screen, but it is still enough to give us an idea of its contents.

The film then jumps around a bit from past to present. The film also jumps from black and white to color, which helps to differentiate scenes from different periods

Most of the rest of the film takes place on one set. This may cause the viewers to feel maddeningly claustrophobic, but this was undoubtedly the filmmaker's intention.

We find out that Gabrielle returned. She is unhappily married to Jean, and she is always going though the motions in public. The couple is living in the lap of luxury, but their great wealth cannot medicate the deep wounds in their relationship.

It's easy to see why she left. Jean seems more concerned about what his friends will say, than discovering what is ailing the marriage.

The only time the couple seems happy is at their lavish, crowded dinner parties.

The film is filled with heavily dramatic, quasi-poetic dialog, which often illuminates the relationship. For instance, Jean admits in the beginning: "I loved her as a collector loves his prized sculpture." Gabrielle later announces to Jean, "The thought of your sperm inside of me is unbearable."

The dialog that Jean thinks about saying is often conveyed by title cards at the same time the action is halted in a freeze frame. The title cards emphasize his unspoken words, and encourage the audience to contemplate the gap between spoken language and thought. The technique was used in a different manner in some of Peter Greenaway's films.

"Gabrielle" doesn't always work, and it is often stagy, phony, and annoyingly artificial. But the film is strong overall, and the powerful emotional effect of the film's final conclusion is difficult to shake off.

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com

Sarah Silverman: Jesus is Magic

Sarah Silverman: Jesus is Magic

Review by Vittorio J. Carli
for Reel Movie Critic

H H H ½

Starring Sarah Silverman

Directed by Liam Lynch. A comedy concert film. Unrated. Roadside Attractions. Running time: 100 minutes.

"Sarah Silverman: Jesus is Magic" is an edgy, invigorating comedy concert film that skillfully incorporates bawdy jokes, song and dance numbers, a preliminary narrative skit, and some mildly amusing mock videos. The film spotlights the considerable comedic talents of Sarah Silverman, a talented and gutsy "Saturday Night Live" show alumni. She also appeared in the film, "The Aristocrats," and she stars in an upcoming cable pilot.

An ingenious short opening section gives the film some context. Off the top of her head, Sarah tells her sister and a friend that she has to leave because she is doing a musical comedy show about Aids and the Holocaust that evening. They ask for tickets. To avoid being labeled a fraud, she puts together a one woman shows in a few hours and even rents a theatre. She decides to cast herself in the lead because she knows she is better than Julia Roberts, Nicole Kidman, and Sandra Bullock.

The standup comedy portion of the film is sharp and topical. Silverman irreverently deals with such subjects as 9/11, sex, religion, and various sex acts. The jokes are all the more effective because there is a disconnect between her sweet delivery and the shocking things she says. She also tends to smile in satisfaction after she says some of the most shocking statements.

Silverman is reminiscent of performance artists like Karen Finely because she revels in breaking language taboos. She also mocks her position as an attractive Jewish American Princess. At one point she says "I can say that because I’m beautiful and white."

She sends up almost all racial and ethnic stereotypes in a mock music video, and calls attention to how ridiculous they all are. She sings: "I love you more than bears love honey: I love you more than Jews love money. I love you more than blacks don’t tip." Besides, this kind of thing was done better in the multi ethnic insult scene in Spike Lee’s "Do the Right Thing."

Silverman often straddles the line that separates hilarity and tastelessness, and many will think she crosses it in this film.

Director Liam Lynch provides some mildly amusing lyrics for the song and dance numbers. But the actual numbers in the film are abominable. Unfortunately, the musical portions halt the film’s momentum and dilute its power. And fortunately the musical sections of the film are short. The poppy hard rock songs are not real rock 'n roll, but cheesy theatrical approximations of it. Perhaps the numbers are supposed to be bad. Silverman’s ironic peppy vocalizing often makes her sound like a shrill, post-modern cheerleader. But her singing’s no worse than Britney Spear’s.

But "Sarah Silverman: Jesus is Magic" inspires more than its share of belly laughs. It’s uneven, but it may be the most hilarious film since "Napoleon Dynamite."

Vittorio J. Carli © 2005

vito@reelmoviecritic.com

Zathura

Home Page      Genres Kids    

In Columbia Pictures heart-racing sci-fi adventure "Zathura," two squabbling brothers are propelled into deepest, darkest space while playing a mysterious game they discovered in the basement of their old house.

On their fantastic journey they are joined by a stranded astronaut and must survive meteor showers, hostile lizard-like aliens, a rocket-propelled robot run amok and an intergalactic spaceship battle.

But their greatest peril lies ahead. For unless they finish the game and reach the planet Zathura, they are doomed to be trapped in outer space forever.

"Zathura" is based on the best-selling book by the acclaimed children's writer Chris Van Allsburg ("The Polar Express," "Jumanji"). With a screenplay by David Koepp. The film stars Josh Hutcherson, Jonah Bobo, Dax Shepard, Kristin Stewart and OSCAR winner Tim Robbins. This film is directed by Jon Favreau (Elf) and produced by Bill Teitler and Michael Deluca.

Running Time: 95 minutes (approximately)

Rated PG by the MPAA for fantasy action and peril, some language.