Home Page      Genres Remake Comedy Feminism
Sci-Fi Romance New York City Musical
Thriller Based on Novel Family Gay

The Stepford Wives

Review by Pam & George O. Singleton
for Reel Movie Critic

H H

Cast

Nicole Kidman Joanna
Matthew Broderick Walter
Bette Midler Bobbi
Christopher Walken Mike Wellington
Directed by Frank Oz. Family satire. Rated PG-13 for sexual content, thematic material and language. Paramount Pictures. Running Time 93 minutes.

Love without love

Joanna (Nicole Kidman of Cold Mountain) is a high-powered TV network president, whose special flare is reality shows, in all their mean-spirited, unrealistic glory. One of her shows, "I Can Do Better" pits Mike White (The School of Rock) and his wife against each other as a happily married couple on an island for a week with high-end professional prostitutes, to see if they will commit adultery. Will they resist temptation or give in because "they can do better?" Let’s just say that the end result finds Joanna looking down a gun barrel…and then out of a job.

With this turn of events Joanna and her husband Walt (Matthew Broderick of You Can Count on Me), who works in her shadow at the same studio, along with their two children, relocate to the idyllic suburb of Stepford, Connecticut. The set up on this is somewhat like Cold Creek Manor, with Sharon Stone and Dennis Quaid, who get fed up with NYC and move to the country where life is supposed to be so much less cutthroat. Both scenarios find high-powered, high profile women with their lives in jeopardy. Hey, do we detect a pattern here?

The houses in the gated community of Stepford are luxurious, and the women who occupy them are a little too cookie cutter friendly in both actions and appearance. Notice, we did not say the women "live" in the houses, for they all seem to not have minds of their own, other than Bobbi (Bette Midler of What Women Want) and Claire (Glenn Close of Cookie’s Fortune.. republish 20031q). Bobbi is a cranky, sarcastic, writer, and she and Joanna recognize they are kindred spirits. Claire, like the other wives of Stepford, is on auto pilot, subservient to her husband ¾ except we sense she clearly is a manipulator with an agenda. Glenn Close could be more frightful than her role in Fatal Attraction, if her character, and the others, as well as the script, didn’t fall apart about 20 minutes into the film.

When one of the Stepford wives has a seizure at a 4th of July celebration, Joanna knows that something is strange when the woman short circuits and starts "sparking." As Joanna becomes more suspicious of her surroundings, Walter starts to embrace the life of his staid men’s club headed by Claire’s husband Mike (the indomitable Christopher Walken of Man on Fire).

We loved the first part of the movie, as Nicole Kidman was edgy and the script had sharp comedy. Not long after Glenn Close welcomed Nicole’s family to Stepford, the drama/thriller part of the film just never hatched. The men were despicable to the point that they were not funny. The high heels and seductive dresses worn by the women on the golf course, as they played caddy for their husbands, was useless sight humor, and Joanna’s baking frenzy was nonsensical. When the comedy part was over the segue to drama fell flat. There was no mystery to the "mysterious goings-on" of the town.

A slowly falling tear that was to break an emotional stalemate telegraphed the key developmental turn of the film. There was some dark humor at the end with Claire and Mike that picked things up a bit, but too little and way too late.

George’s Take: For a movie about an idyllic town where things are not as they appear rent Dogville. Ironically, it also stars Nicole Kidman and it’s a brilliant film.

Pam’s Take: The original "Stepford Wives," made in 1975, was not a great film but there were elements of mystery, some humor and a touch of horror. All of that is missing here.

George O. Singleton © 2004

george@reelmoviecritic.com