Genres: Comedy Coming of Age African-American
Asian-America Gay-Lesbian Teen  

Mean Girls

Reviewed by Pam & George O. Singleton  
 

H H H½

Cast

Lindsay Lohan Cady
Tina Fey Ms. Norbury
Rachel McAdams Regina
Tim Meadows Mr. Duvall
Directed by Mark S. Waters ("Freaky Friday"). A coming of age comedy. Rated PG-13 for sexual content, language and some teen partying. Paramount Pictures.
 

Unwritten rules

Cady (Lindsay Lohan of "Freaky Friday") is a 16-year-old, entering an American school setting for the first time. She has spent the last 12 years in Africa with her zoologist parents, and has been "home schooled." So, Cady is plunging into the deep end of the pool of high school, and those "mean girls" are waiting for her. The film is based upon the New York Times bestseller, "Queen Bees and Wannabes: Helping Your Daughter Survive Cliques, Gossip, Boyfriends and Other Realities of Adolescence." The book is praised as being, "A chilling account of life our girls navigate in their school lunchrooms and hallways."

Student behavior in high school is in many ways more animalistic in character than Cady has observed by lions and baboons in the bush of Africa. The first day in school is a disaster and the second is not much better. She can’t sit at certain open desks in the classroom or the lunchroom because of various social conventions. Cady is befriended¾ and that term is used loosely¾ by two gay teens, Damian (Daniel Franzese, "Bully") and Janis (Lizzy Caplan, "Orange County"), who have their own agenda for revenge against the "plastics;" those girls who are phony and not real. They suggest a way for Cady to get back at her tormentors, who are reminiscent of the "nearly lost girls" in "Thirteen." Cady’s initially innocent actions toward Regina (Rachel McAdams), Gretchen (Lacey Chabert, "Daddy Day Care") and Karen (Amanda Seyfried, TVs "All My Children") soon result in her replacing Regina as the "skank b----," a term often used in the film. Spoiler alert: Regina does discover her inner self and finds a way to redemption. Perhaps this was the filmmaker’s road to redemption for some of the teen angst he peddles here.

Self-esteem issues are paramount. What if you’re not "Cover Girl" beautiful? Do you want to be "like a virgin" or what? The spirit of the mean girls is best captured in the group’s alternative yearbook, a scrapbook that focuses only on the negative. It’s called the "Burn Book" and written next to the picture of the girl or boy is something meant to demean that individual.

The dialogue is quick and believable. The situations are recognizable as well. Cady is a whiz at math but she allows herself to be dumbed-down so she can fit in and be liked by the most handsome boy in school, Aaron (Jonathan Bennett). Principal Duvall (Tim Meadows) must deal with unruly, undisciplined students on one hand as well as teachers who are accused of abuse, sometimes true and sometimes not. The leader of the Mathletes (math jocks) team is Rajiv (Kevin Gnapoor), an Asian American hip hopper, who assumes that Janis is Puerto Rican when in fact she is Lebanese. You don’t have to be white or a blue blood to stereotype others. Be in a minority and you’d be surprised at how readily one, including other minorities, can conclude "you all look alike."

The story certainly passes the cuteness factor, yet it has some of the same messages as in the far edgier, R rated, Oscar nominated "Thirteen." We continue to be amazed at what a flesh market high school has become. The importance of being desirable in an explicitly sexual way appears to carry far more weight than in years past.

Most of the coming-of-age films aimed at teens that deal realistically with serious issues of high school students are R rated. This one gets a strong recommendation because it’s pretty darn good and comes in with a PG-13 rating. Not many young actresses could pull that off, but Lohan has the acting chops to give it that balance. "Mean Girls" has an edge but it always remains a comedy.

George O. Singleton © 2004

george@reelmoviecritic.com