| Top 10 Lists of 2003 | Media Outlet | |
| Shelley Cameron | Reel Movie Critic | |
| Vittorio J. Carli | Reel Movie Critic | |
| Mark Caro | Chicago Tribune | |
| Cathy Edsey Collins | Reel Movie Critic | |
| Joseph M. Davis | Reel Movie Critic | |
| Roger Ebert | Chicago Sun Times | |
| Bob Mondello | National Public Radio | |
| Richard Roeper | Chicago Sun Times | |
| Brenda Sexton | Reel Movie Critic | |
| Lee Shoquist | Reel Movie Critic | |
| George Singleton | Reel Movie Critic | |
| Pam Singleton | Reel Movie Critic | |
| Michael Wilmington | Chicago Tribune | |