DVD
The Luzhin Defence ***1/2 (PG-13)
|
Reviewed By George O. Singleton
|
No answer is sometimes the answer
|
Alex Luzhin: John Turturro
|
Natalia: Emily Watson
|
Alex's father: Mark Tandy
|
Alex's mother: Kelly Hunter
|
Young Alex: Alexander Hunting
|
Aunt Anna: Orla Brady
|
Valentinov: Stuart Wilson
|
Natalia's mother: Geraldine James
|
Turati: Fabio Sartor
|
Jean de Stassard: Christopher Thompson
|
Director: Marleen Gorris
|
 |
30 Second Bottom Line: Two lovers, one a chess master and the other a socialite, try to develop a life together even though many oppose their relationship.
Story Line: Alex Luzhin (John Turturro) is at a seaside resort in Lake Como, Italy for a world chess championship, where he is expected to be in the finals with Turati (Fabio Sartor). As a young boy, Alex (Alexander Hunting) learned that he was skilled at chess, as he was able to out maneuver the grown men at the local chess club. When he was truant from school and his father learned he was playing chess he wanted to teach Alex a lesson, only to be taught one himself, due to Alex's gift.
Alex's life was strained because his father (Mark Tandy) was a strict disciplinarian at home, but a free spirit when away on outings with his sister-in-law, Anna (Orla Brady). Alex's mother (Kelly Hunter) did not like to do things like ride on roller coasters, as her sister Anna would do with Alex and his father. His mother became a bitter and jealous woman. After her death, Alex's father placed him in the care of a chess mentor, Valentinov (Stuart Wilson). Besides, this freed his father to have more time with Anna.
Later in life, when Alex is pushing 40 years old, he refers to his years with Valentinov as "the lost years." Valentinov made a nice amount of money off of the winnings that Alex earned in chess clubs on the Continent, and his desire was to take him to the professional level. However, Alex did not thrive under intense formal competition and when Alex refused to go to America to help Valentinov make his fortune, they split up.
Now, many years later, Valentinov reunites with Luzhin at the championships, pretending to be a friend. When Turati asks Valentinov "Do you want me to win, or do you want Luzhin to lose?" Valentinov chooses not to answer. His silence says it all.
Luzhin meets Natalia Karkhov (Emily Watson), a young socialite, as he is taking a walk on the grounds of the resort, all the while making notes of possible combinations of moves in the upcoming chess matches. She picks up something that drops from his tattered pockets. Tattered also describes Luzhin's demeanor, both in how he relates to people, as well as how he looks. His world is chess; his conversation is chess; he knows nothing other than chess. But he falls in love with Natalia instantly, and she is captivated by his intensity.
Natalia's mother (Geraldine James), an aristocrat from Russia, wants her to marry a French count, Jean de Stassard (Christopher Thompson), who is also attending the matches. She is horrified when she meets and talks to Alex, and tries to convince Natalia that Jean is much better suited for her. Natalia and Luzhin are attracted to each other and they become the soul mates each may have never known they were looking for. They are, indeed, the odd couple, who manages to bring true passion and love into their lives for the first time. Still, that does not mean there will be a happy ending.
Tell Me More About It: The Luzhin Defence is a fascinating story, adapted from the novel by Vladimir Nabokov. At first it appears to be a film about winning an important chess match, with a love story coming together at the same time. What we learn is that it's about people finding out who they are and then trying to determine if they can find happiness against considerable odds. For Luzhin, chess has driven him to the point of insanity and his only salvation appears to be to give up the game. Just as he fell in love with chess right away as a child, the same is the case when he meets Natalia. Love, perhaps more so than chess, seems to be in his future.
Natalia and Luzhin are on the brink of having him focus on the love between them, to save his sanity, when Valentinov begins to manipulate things, to pressure Luzhin. Valentinov's plan is to have the pleasure of seeing him lose to Turati in the championship match.
As with the movie The House of Mirth, you may leave the theater feeling good about some things and frustrated about others. Not only because of the film itself, but the reality of facing life. There is a great element of perseverance portrayed in this film, tempered with an ultimate surrender. Turturro and Watson both deliver outstanding performances, and their characters' relationship, while having two seemingly very different personalities, shows that opposites really do attract.
However, just because some things ought to be, does not mean they will be. Life often is not fair…that is life.
PG-13 (mature themes and some sensuality)
|
George O. Singleton © 2001
|
|
|
Mini Filmography
|
|
Emily Watson: Angela's Ashes
|
Mark Tandy: Food of Love
|
Kelly Hunter: Life Force-TV
|
Alexander Hunting: Debut
|
Orla Brady: Wuthering Heights-TV
|
Stuart Wilson: Enemy of the State
|
Geraldine James: Gold-TV
|
Fabio Sartor: Jesus-TV
|
Christopher Thompson: Waiting
|
Marleen Gorris: Antonia's Line
|
 |
|